AD&D is what OD&D was starting to be. When E. Gary Gygax sat down to solidify his open notes of OD&D into the more concrete rule books of AD&D, he spent a lot of time explaining what he actually meant by the rules and pinning them with mechanics. Unfortunately in the process, he included a lot of extra elements that complicated or contradicted the rest of the structure. To really understand the game of OD&D, you must add to it cues from AD&D, or take AD&D and subtract elements from it until you return to a game that's like OD&D.
Most players, on the other hand, want to play the game their way, and rather use OD&D as a springboard for their own Fantastic Medieval Wargames Campaign, with the elements they like and rules assumptions that they prefer. And that was the original intent of OD&D all along.
Wednesday, May 26, 2021
The relationship between OD&D and AD&D
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Your single-minded opinions are refreshing (considering the communities I find myself in).
ReplyDeleteHave you looked at OD&D retroclones? I myself have checked out Delving Deeper which seems to hew very close to the OG rules.
I haven’t. Most other OD&D retroclones change too much from the game for me to be comfortable. The game that is the most comfortable for me to run is...straight OD&D
Delete