Friday, November 19, 2021

 ranting on discord, copying it here:

B/X is a broken as fuck system. It wasn’t written with an eye towards what plays well, but what reads well. It’s a simplified version of OD&D that tosses out a lot of nuance that makes that game playable. It also contains a mishmash of AD&D elements. “Playtesting”, in regards to BX, is a joke concept.
It’s also a very limited system. BX advertises 14 levels but in reality games fizzle out between levels 6-9, because there isn’t much to do beyond delve into dungeons and travel in between dungeons. BX has wilderness encounters numbering in the 100’s of monsters, but no method to resolve combat at that scale. In OD&D it’s assumed that you would play out the battle using miniatures and the Chainmail rules, BX has no replacement system and no mention of Chainmail. BX mentions the creation of strongholds, but no details on how to do so, what their purpose is, or how to manage them. Even AD&D describes how strongholds can manage henchman and followers.
There’s a reason BX “hacks” and supplements are so popular: you simply need more rules, if you want to play a game that’s more than dungeon crawling with 7 character types. Not “classes”, BX actually just gives you 7 characters that you can modify cosmetically and just play

2e isn’t for everyone. 2e is a fantasy world simulator, and in my very biased opinion, it’s the best at that task. It creates a fantastical world that runs on something approaching real world logic, and gives you the opportunity to run any fantasy in that world. With only some tweaks you can use it to run things wildly different than the standard setting, for example Dark Sun, Ravenloft, Spelljammer.
2e is a very expansive game, with a lot of rules. It’s not as rules heavy as 3e or even 1e, but it has a supplement for seemingly everything. The core 2e books are intentionally a reaction against 1e’s heavy handed authoritarian style, and presents most of the rules as options that you could slot into your campaign. The thing I don’t like about them though is the writing style and organization. The split between DMG and PHB was a mistake
Mostly, 2e cleans up 1e, fixes most of the obvious contradictions and ambiguities, and presents a core game that runs really well as a light system if you don’t use any optional rules, or a fully simulationist system if you do.
Unfortunately the greatest drawback of 2e is the ‘90s and the TTRPG community at the time. They wanted rules for everything, heavy simulationist approaches, the option to chuck dice at all times, at the cost of imagination. 2e splats followed some very bad trends that eventually left the game abandoned for trendier games like World of Darkness or GURPS. the “rules for everything” approach reached its apotheosis in 3rd edition, which is when everyone realized that it was a bad idea
Though, as a point in its favor, 2e actually has two (three?) mass combat systems, and at least one of them, Battle System, is actually very good. As a result of the splatbook explosion, 2e allows you to play a full game from lowly dungeon delver to domain ruler to Planescape jumper with plenty of official support. BECMI is the only other TSR edition that does that

Monday, October 11, 2021

Retrofitting Mythic into D&D

 I've tried a lot of solo systems, and I keep coming back to Mythic, because every other system just feels like a stripped down version of Mythic. Except the PbtA ones, I guess.

 Mythic doesn't really work with D&D, however, since Mythic assumes a cinematic approach to gaming and D&D assumes a simulationist one. In Mythic, game play is divided into a sequence of scenes, where scenes are chosen in respect to how they push the story forward, and do not have to play out in a linear order and all the unnecessary events in between are ignored. This doesn't really fit D&D's simulationist approach, which doesn't divide cleanly into discrete scenes and the "unnecessary" mechanics of the journey are in fact the greater part of the game. 

But I think that Mythic can be salvaged for use in old school D&D by hacking off the parts that work and repurposing them; specifically Threads, Lists, Events, and Chaos Factor.

Threads are basically the goals of your character, as an end goal like "killing the demon lord" or something on the side like "finding long-lost brother". Mythic has many tools for managing threads and manipulating them at unexpected times. Creating, following, and resolving threads adds a story-driven direction to the game.

Events are the meat and potatoes of the solo engine. Everything revolves around them and most of the solo game will be spent dealing with the consequences of an event. Use events in place of a random encounter. Perform the random encounter check as normal, and on a success turn to Mythic’s event generation rules and fit what happens. The Mythic GME constantly stresses that Events should be defined by the context of the game, and D&D provides the context, whether overland, in town or in the dungeon.

Lists and List Management are necessary paperwork for tracking and manipulating Threads and NPCs in your game. Only add “important” NPCs to the list, as in D&D you’ll probably be generating a lot. When a thread or event states to “Introduce NPC”, that would be one important to the story and should be built accordingly. The 1e DMG has a table of traits for random NPC generation, which I found to be more straightforward than the Mythic one, but has more limited options.

The Fate check is introduced in the Mythic GME as it’s most important mechanic, but I found it’s usefulness limited in old school D&D, as there are usually more concrete procedures for resolving in-game activities. Nevertheless, there are points where procedures or results are unknown, and it’s there that the Fate check comes into play. I recommend using the Fate check from Variations 2.

Most people who play solo don’t like to use Chaos Factor, but I do. I like the element of randomness and the unexpected that it provides. 

I have the Mythic cards, and generally I prefer them for tracking Chaos factor and Lists, but for events and the other checks I like to use Variations 2. 

Friday, September 24, 2021

Silvering of weapons

 The reason Dracula, of Bram Stoker’s Dracula, hated silver was because it was considered a “pure” metal, as opposed to steel which was an alloy, or gold which was too soft to kill in its purest form. It is also why Dracula had no reflection, because mirrors of the time were backed by silver.

D&D Rules allow silver weapons to harm certain monsters, and players expect to exploit a loophole to create silver weapons by melting down silver coins and coating their regular weapons with it. In strict terms, this wouldn’t harm the Dracula from the book, because it is not the chemical properties of silver/Ag, but the “purity” of the creation made from it. Silvering a mundane weapon does not create a pure weapon. 

Players want to melt silver coins because it is cheaper to do so than to buy a new weapon. The way to make such cost commensurate would be to use a silver standard.



Friday, September 17, 2021

 Allowing players free movement over a map makes keeping STRICT TIME RECORDS practically impossible, especially with dynamic lighting. It’s easiest to do in “theater of the mind” style where the DM is effectively in control of the pace of the party. 

In OD&D, all magical armor is plate armor. Using only the LBBs, this isn’t so much an issue as 2/3 classes can wear magical plate with no restrictions, and the class that can’t, cant wear any armor anyway.
But the thief poses an issue, as that class can wear some limited armor, but not the better armors, and no magical armor.
Meaning that the Thief is practically just as bad as the MU. Worse, actually, as higher level MUs can make up for this deficiency where Thieves never can.

Saturday, August 7, 2021

Mass combat and the wilderness

 I’ve been thinking about mass battles lately, and how the wilderness crawl was originally supposed to be a mass battle campaign. One only needs to look at the movement rates and encounter numbers to see clues for that. But the d20 combat system doesn’t support mass battles well.


And then I thought about how much actual combat sucks, especially for those low level characters between levels 1-3. Indeed, in D&D it feels like your individual character is just some nameless, highly disposable grunt in a dungeon. In fact it feels like if you want any success in a dungeon expedition, one must lead a whole platoon into it and only come out with the survivors.


And maybe that’s where a hidden genius of the design lies. Instead of playing as super capable heroes, you and your friends must take the role of disposable grunts and band together. Where in a wargame you would control a whole squad yourself, in D&D you just control an individual member of that squad. So you and your friends must coordinate and work as a team to survive. OSR is essentially a teamwork game.


Coming back to mass battles, maybe there’s another secret to the way wilderness works - by the time you’re wilderness adventuring, your characters should be at least level 4 - which in Chainmail terms is the level that they fight using the Hero rules. And Heroes and above can fight at the mass battle 1:20 scale. So maybe that tight knight squad you formed down in the dungeon is now wilderness adventuring, and each member of that squad now fights as 4 men. Suddenly their chances of survival are more favorable. 

And of course, by the time one is ready to start campaigning in the world, he should be able to raise and equip an army of hirelings to fight for him as well. 

Sunday, August 1, 2021

Why does a treasure cache contain 1,000 copper pieces?

Because the designer wanted to give you 10 XP, but he wanted you to pay for it by carrying 1000 coins around in weight.

When I ran 5e, I felt like I was fighting the system itself in order to run any kind of campaign through it, as characters had too many spec...